Monday, January 9, 2012

Wandering Monsters and GNS

So, Fr. Dave's startlingly acute insight into the role of the Wandering Monster Table got me to thinking (an aside: this is at least the second post that comes from thinking about something that worthy said).  Basically, what FD did was take a mental step to the side and look at the concept of the Wandering Monster from a new light.  In the comments, I noted that his particular shift of POV made me think of yet  another.  As I walked around on my afternoon constitutional, I thought more about this and it occurred to me that here is a place where the GNS Theory (which I never hear discussed anymore) might be useful.

I have always had a troubled relationship with Wandering Monsters in Ye Auld Game.  I honestly didn't even understand the idea when I started playing and ignored it.  Later, I began to understand the idea, but seldom used it because something about it bugged me.  I didn't have the conceptual tools to understand why it bothered me; it just did.  It is clearer now to me that my problem has something to do with how one answers the question, "Why are these 2d6 Skeletons wandering around here?"

When you look at early dungeons, it is pretty clear that the answer to the above questions is something like, "Because that's a decent encounter for this level of the dungeon."  It is an implicitly Gamist concept, in which monster Hit Dice are related to Dungeon Level, and the whole thing has to do discouraging dawdling and noisy war-bands.  That's not to say that one could not provide some in-game rationale, but any such rationale would be an ex post facto invention on the part of the Referee and not the intent of the encounter.

That's what truly irritated me about Wandering Monsters because I was, in the GNS Model, a determined Simulationist, trying hard to play in a world that felt "real".  I wanted to know why it was skeletons, why it was 2d6 of them, and why they were on this particular level and not another (you couldn't even appeal to idea that monsters stick to levels where they won't get eaten by something tougher, because skeletons don't really have any sense of self-preservation).  I wanted a Table that was specifically designed for each locale instead of the endless supply of Giant Rats and Hobgoblins.  But trying to put those together was so much work that I usually just gave up entirely.

Now, what strikes me a so damn clever about Fr. Dave's idea is the way it promotes a Narrativist agenda for the Wandering Monster Table.  And, yes, I wrote that precisely - it makes the Table itself a player in the game, with agency, and a say in the unfolding narrative.  This point-of-view makes it explicit that there is a non-Gamist answer to my question, but still requires the Referee to flesh it out.  These might be the only 2d6 Skeletons in the dungeon, or in the world, and if they are destroyed, there aren't any more.  Unless, that is, they come up again on the Table, at which point some intriguing narrative is surely unfolding: are the skeletons unkillable, rising up again a few hours after being destroyed?  Is there an enthusiastic necromancer just ahead of the party, practicing his art to keep them delayed?  Are the skeletons the unquiet remnants of living monsters killed by the party, chasing them for revenge?

I don't know, but suddenly the whole enterprise seems so much more interesting to me.

73 comments:

  1. Wandering Monsters could be seen like Fumble tables, just more random obstacles.

    But they were also a weird entertainment for the DM in his story. They were a mini-game within the game to force the DM to be surprised and to improvise as if he were a player.

    ReplyDelete
  2. One of the things that 2E implemented, was that they're a starting point--you were intended to create ones suitable for the environment/dungeon you were inside.

    You theme the adventure with them. Of course my Random Encounter Table was more than monsters, it included all the fun stuff I wanted. Strange things, wondrous things, weather, sounds.

    I had a haunted grave yard that's wandering encounter was:

    A gate creaks
    A howling can be heard.
    A ghost rises from a grave and passes the characters, ignoring them completely.
    A skeleton is digging up a body, it will turn and attack if characters linger to long.
    A hand reaches up and grabs a character's ankle.


    Spiced in with the planned events these random encounters gave flavor to the haunted graveyard, without it all being combat/combat/combat.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Wandering monsters served a very important purpose: Keeping the characters moving. If you think about it, in AD&D they were part and parcel to tracking turns and torches -- they gave a sense of urgency. As in, "we can't rest here because we're going to die!"

    ReplyDelete
  4. Too damned funny. I look up Wheel of Samsara to make sure my reference is appropriate (too many years since Zen Philosophy class), and I find a nearby friend. Hello Matt! While your blog doesn't particularly suit the nature of my search, it is rather fun to find you out here in the google wilderness, proving, perhaps, ...well proving something about worlds and smallness and so on. Even on the internet.

    --Emeline's dad

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hah! The turnings of the Wheel are mysterious indeed.

    ReplyDelete
  6. rationale would be an ex post factor invention on the part of the Referee and not the intent of the encounter.

    dallas seo consulting

    ReplyDelete
  7. You might hear the response: “Awwwwwwww! That was so sweet. You´re so cute. I want to hug you like my Teddybear.
    online shopping engine
    best price online shopping

    ReplyDelete
  8. One of the most beautiful qualities of true friendship is to understand and to be understood.
    Online Shopping Engine
    price comparison engine
    Best Price Online Shopping Engine

    ReplyDelete
  9. If you're interested in saving money on energy bills visit my website.
    Power to Choose

    ReplyDelete
  10. “You know you're in love when you can't fall asleep because reality is finally better than your dreams.”
    Online Shopping Engine
    Price Comparison Engine
    Best Price Online Shopping Engine

    ReplyDelete
  11. @Compare Electric Plans|@Commercial Electric Rates Texas|@Texas Electric Choice
    Dwarves aren't native to the Weird opera world, but then, Ibbo isn't from this world. He comes from a foreign planet situated in another universe
    Compare Electric Plans
    Commercial Electric Rates Texas
    Texas Electric Choice
    Compare Electric Plans
    Compare Electric Plans
    Power to choose
    Texas Electric Company
    Compare Electric Rates
    Texas Electric Rates

    ReplyDelete
  12. I wanted to know why it was skeletons, why it was 2d6 of them, and why they were on this particular level and not another (you couldn't even appeal to idea that monsters stick to levels where they won't get eaten by something tougher, because skeletons don't really have any sense of self-preservation).!!!
    @Compare Electric Rates-|@Compare Electric Plans-|@Texas Electric Company-|@Texas Electric Rates-
    Texas Electric Company

    Compare Electric Rates

    Texas Electric Rates

    Power to Choose

    Compare Electric Plans

    ReplyDelete
  13. Compare electric rates Texas Making an energy choice that is efficient can make a big difference in the cost of your energy bill. No need of a major investment in time or money to make sure you’re wasting less energy and saving more. Commercial Texas electric rates If your dryer isn’t providing enough heat or moving air sufficiently through the clothes, then you might have noticed they are taking longer to dry, and at times, not dry at all. Compare Electric Rates Making an energy choice that is efficient can make a big difference in the cost of your energy bill. No need of a major investment in time or money to make sure you’re wasting less energy and saving more. Texas Electric Rates place heat-resistant reflectors between radiators and walls. In the winter, this will help heat the room instead of the wall. Texas Electric Company To keep out the heat of the summer sun, close window shades, and drapes in warm weather and also pay less for power in turn. Power to Choose but also to save water by scraping dishes instead of rinsing them before loading in the dishwasher.Compare Electric Plans Most dishwashers are designed to thoroughly clean dishes that have food scraps, as compared to rinsing off. Commercial Electric Rates Texas If your dryer isn’t providing enough heat or moving air sufficiently through the clothes, then you might have noticed they are taking longer to dry, and at times, not dry at all. Compare electric plans Texas summaries the inevitable bill shock into four stages! Best electric providers Texas its energy-efficiency and also to what kind of weather the home normally sees during the heat. So, choose energy, wisely!Compare electric TX

    ReplyDelete
  14. Compare electric rates Texas Making an energy choice that is efficient can make a big difference in the cost of your energy bill. No need of a major investment in time or money to make sure you’re wasting less energy and saving more. Commercial Texas electric rates If your dryer isn’t providing enough heat or moving air sufficiently through the clothes, then you might have noticed they are taking longer to dry, and at times, not dry at all. Compare Electric Rates Making an energy choice that is efficient can make a big difference in the cost of your energy bill. No need of a major investment in time or money to make sure you’re wasting less energy and saving more. Texas Electric Rates place heat-resistant reflectors between radiators and walls. In the winter, this will help heat the room instead of the wall. Texas Electric Company To keep out the heat of the summer sun, close window shades, and drapes in warm weather and also pay less for power in turn. Power to Choose but also to save water by scraping dishes instead of rinsing them before loading in the dishwasher.Compare Electric Plans Most dishwashers are designed to thoroughly clean dishes that have food scraps, as compared to rinsing off. Commercial Electric Rates Texas If your dryer isn’t providing enough heat or moving air sufficiently through the clothes, then you might have noticed they are taking longer to dry, and at times, not dry at all. Compare electric plans Texas summaries the inevitable bill shock into four stages! Best electric providers Texas its energy-efficiency and also to what kind of weather the home normally sees during the heat. So, choose energy, wisely!Compare electric TX

    ReplyDelete
  15. Compare electric rates Texas Making an energy choice that is efficient can make a big difference in the cost of your energy bill. No need of a major investment in time or money to make sure you’re wasting less energy and saving more. Commercial Texas electric rates If your dryer isn’t providing enough heat or moving air sufficiently through the clothes, then you might have noticed they are taking longer to dry, and at times, not dry at all. Compare Electric Rates Making an energy choice that is efficient can make a big difference in the cost of your energy bill. No need of a major investment in time or money to make sure you’re wasting less energy and saving more. Texas Electric Rates place heat-resistant reflectors between radiators and walls. In the winter, this will help heat the room instead of the wall. Texas Electric Company To keep out the heat of the summer sun, close window shades, and drapes in warm weather and also pay less for power in turn. Power to Choose but also to save water by scraping dishes instead of rinsing them before loading in the dishwasher.Compare Electric Plans Most dishwashers are designed to thoroughly clean dishes that have food scraps, as compared to rinsing off. Commercial Electric Rates Texas If your dryer isn’t providing enough heat or moving air sufficiently through the clothes, then you might have noticed they are taking longer to dry, and at times, not dry at all. Compare electric plans Texas summaries the inevitable bill shock into four stages! Best electric providers Texas its energy-efficiency and also to what kind of weather the home normally sees during the heat. So, choose energy, wisely!Compare electric TX

    ReplyDelete
  16. I have always had a troubled relationship with Wandering Monsters in Ye Auld Game. I honestly didn't even understand the idea when I started playing and ignored it.
    Power to Choose

    Power to Choose

    ReplyDelete
  17. I was diagnosed with COPD with 55-60% lung capacity. My doctor just said all the crying , stomping your feet will not change it so just accept it and basically patted me on the back and sent me home to die. I was devastated and was afraid to do anything. I stopped riding my bike, I was afraid to do anything that would cause any exertion. It consumed my thoughts with every breath and the fear of what to expect was almost more than I could deal with. So I couldn't get myself all time I decided to find a herbal cure online and I came acrose Doctor Itua on how he cure several people suffering from Hiv, and Herpes I gave him a call on this Number +2348149277967 also chat on whatsapp he gave me all the details about the cure i paid him for the medicine after 5 working days i receieve my herbal medicine ,I use it for two weeks that is how I get Cured and today I'm living healthy and fine I give him thanks also promise him to testify about his work,He Can also cure the following diseases..Copd,Herpes,Alzheimer's disease,carcinoma.Asthma,Allergic diseases.Parkinson's ,Epilepsy,Cancer,Fibromyalgia,Hiv,Hepatitis,diabetes,Coeliac disease,Infertility, Asthma.Contact...drituaherbalcenter@gmail.com..Whatsapp Number...+2348149277976

    ReplyDelete
  18. Sell4bids is the amazing and fastest growing application to Sell and Buy used stuff locally. Over ten thousand downloads and 500 thousand listings! Find great deals, from used DVDs, CDs, Movies like Avengers Endgame, clothes, bikes and Xbox games to furniture, cars and home.
    Buy used stuff
    Sell and Buy used stuff
    Sell Buy used stuff
    used stuff locally

    ReplyDelete
  19. You can check content from your own web site to create positive no one else has been rending you off!

    Plagiarism checker free


    Plagiariam checker online



    Plagiarism detector free

    ReplyDelete
  20. You can check content from your own web site to create positive no one else has been rending you off!

    Plagiarism checker free

    Plagiariam checker online

    Plagiarism detector free

    ReplyDelete

  21. You can check content from your own web site to create positive no one else has been rending you off!

    Plagiarism checker free

    Plagiarism checker online

    Plagiarism detector free

    ReplyDelete
  22. WEB EASY is a leading Web Development Company in Pakistan.They are well known in this field SEO Services Pakistan. Their services include WordPress theme development, Custom web development, and Digital Marketing services.WEB EASY is Digital Marketing Agency Pakistan specializing in web design, web development, e-commerce.
    SEO Agency Pakistan
    SEO Provider Pakistan
    SEO Packages Pakistan
    Web Development Company

    ReplyDelete
  23. State-funded schools are experiencing strain to accomplish more with less cash while enhancing understudy execution, all while obliging the requirements of an extensive variety of understudies. RFP search engine is available which will give you the education bids and other RFPS for digital learn. This has prompted an ascent in government contracts for advancing computerized realizing.

    RFP Bid sites
    RFP Bidding sites
    RFP Sites
    best rfp database
    RFP Aggregator

    ReplyDelete
  24. islamic books center
    islamic books center where you can purchase English, Urdu, Sindhi, Persian, Arabic Islamic books and many more

    best islamic books.Pak Company has played a vital role in the field of knowledge.The purpose of this website is to provide the best islamic books free of errors.
    Pak Company which is a islamic books center provides these best islamic books
    Holy Quran
    Punj Surah
    Manzil
    Namaz
    Majmua Wazaif
    and many more.

    best islamic books
    quran translation in urdu
    online quran
    islamic books center
    Pak Company

    ReplyDelete
  25. Our website is designed to streamline the entire shopping experience of our
    customers and visitors alike. With our site, you will find all company jcp coupon code and promos lined up in a common segment. We have a segment dedicated directly to the EnglandRugbyStore Coupons and amazon promo code.

    ReplyDelete

  26. CV SARKAR Provide Jobs in Pakistan. Best online job portal in Pakistan Post best jobs in Pakistan and latest jobs in Pakistan. Update new jobs, daily jobs in Pakistan.


    jobs in pakistan

    jobs in lahore

    jobs in karachi

    jobs in Islamabad

    jobs in Multan

    ReplyDelete
  27. INSTEAD OF GETTING A LOAN,, I GOT SOMETHING NEW
    Get $5,500 USD every day, for six months!

    See how it works
    Do you know you can hack into any Credit cards machine with a hacked Credit cards??
    Make up your mind before applying, straight deal...

    Order for a blank Credit cards now and get millions within a week!: contact us
    via email address:: {Legitblankcardsonline@gmail.com}

    We have specially programmed Credits Cards that can be use to hack Credit cards Machines
    Nation Wide, the Credits Cards can be used to withdraw at any Credits Cards or swipe Machines, at
    Stores and POS Machines. We sell this cards to all our customers and interested
    buyers worldwide, the Credit Card has a daily withdrawal limit of $5,500 at any Credit cards Machines
    and up to $50,000 spending limit in stores depending on the kind of card
    you order for. Credits Cards Can also be used in any other cyber hack{Services}, we are here for you anytime any day.

    Here is our price lists for the Credits Cards:

    Cards that withdraw $5,500 per day costs $200 USD
    Cards that withdraw $10,000 per day costs $850 USD
    Cards that withdraw $35,000 per day costs $2,200 USD
    Cards that withdraw $50,000 per day costs $5,500 USD
    Cards that withdraw $100,000 per day costs $8,500 USD


    make up your mind before applying, straight deal!!!

    The price include shipping fees and charges, order now: contact us via
    email address:: {Legitblankcardsonline@gmail.com}

    ReplyDelete